your-land/bugtracker
your-land
/
bugtracker
44
20
Code Issues 2.5k Projects 2 Wiki

mob spawn balancing #5691

New Issue
Open
opened 2023-12-14 07:16:29 +00:00 by AliasAlreadyTaken · 23 comments
AliasAlreadyTaken commented 2023-12-14 07:16:29 +00:00
Owner
Copy Link

Please comment here if you found something odd in mob spawning on YL.

Please comment here if you found something odd in mob spawning on YL.
AliasAlreadyTaken added the
4. step/help wanted
4. step/discussion
1. kind/balancing
 labels 2023-12-14 07:16:46 +00:00
AliasAlreadyTaken added the
2. prio/interesting
 label 2023-12-14 07:19:56 +00:00
flux commented 2023-12-18 19:07:05 +00:00
Member
Copy Link

petz in particular seem to spawn far too often, which is odd, as they should be relatively rarer individually than most other common mobs.

petz in particular seem to spawn far too often, which is odd, as they should be relatively rarer individually than most other common mobs.
flux commented 2023-12-18 20:50:17 +00:00
Member
Copy Link

individual spawn counts of mobs in a 24 hour period, from Alias. note that some mobs, e.g. petz:wolf, spawn in clusters, so their numbers are inflated:

Counter({'yl_nether_mobs:whip': 2300,
         'mobs_mime:mime': 2072,
         'petz:wolf': 1554,
         'nether_mobs:netherman': 1547,
         'petz:tarantula': 1526,
         'yl_nether_mobs:witherskeleton': 1412,
         'yl_nether_mobs:rat': 1312,
         'mobs_monster:oerkki': 1271,
         'water_life:snake': 1237,
         'mobs_monster:stone_monster': 1217,
         'petz:bat': 1200,
         'yl_nether_mobs:evoker': 1038,
         'mobs_animal:rat': 957,
         'yl_nether_mobs:ogre': 956,
         'petz:bunny': 902,
         'petz:piggy': 868,
         'water_life:gull': 862,
         'scorpion:little': 855,
         'mobs_ghost_redo:ghost': 771,
         'petz:squirrel': 715,
         'petz:pony': 595,
         'mobs_animal:bunny': 593,
         'yl_nether_mobs:wither': 585,
         'mobs_monster:spider': 555,
         'petz:hamster': 535,
         'petz:silkworm': 530,
         'petz:moth': 488,
         'mobs_monster:tree_monster': 471,
         'petz:lamb': 470,
         'petz:foxy': 465,
         'petz:calf': 452,
         'mobs_animal:sheep_white': 446,
         'petz:goat': 436,
         'mobs_animal:kitten': 430,
         'water_life:gecko': 418,
         'petz:grizzly': 399,
         'petz:kitty': 346,
         'yl_nether_mobs:blaze': 340,
         'mobs_monster:dirt_monster': 333,
         'mobs_animal:cow': 320,
         'mobs_animal:chicken': 314,
         'petz:dolphin': 290,
         'petz:pigeon': 285,
         'petz:rat': 270,
         'mobs_animal:pumba': 253,
         'mobs_others:snow_walker': 251,
         'yl_nether_mobs:iron_golem': 236,
         'mobs_umbra:umbra': 228,
         'petz:queen_ant': 217,
         'petz:turtle': 215,
         'petz:elephant_female': 213,
         'mobs_gazer:gazer': 201,
         'mobs_animal:bee': 200,
         'mobs_monster:dungeon_master': 196,
         'petz:elephant': 196,
         'petz:gecko': 194,
         'petz:flamingo': 194,
         'water_life:piranha': 193,
         'petz:ducky': 192,
         'petz:puppy': 187,
         'petz:hen': 182,
         'mobs_monster:mese_monster': 179,
         'water_life:fish': 179,
         'petz:frog': 178,
         'petz:butterfly': 171,
         'petz:lion': 167,
         'mobs_monster:land_guard': 147,
         'water_life:jellyfish': 143,
         'petz:leopard': 136,
         'petz:chimp': 127,
         'petz:parrot': 126,
         'petz:panda': 122,
         'water_life:coralfish': 122,
         'water_life:clams': 116,
         'mobs_animal:panda': 114,
         'water_life:shark': 112,
         'petz:toucan': 103,
         'petz:beaver': 85,
         'mobs_monster:lava_flan': 81,
         'petz:camel': 76,
         'mobs_animal:sheep_black': 74,
         'petz:queen_bee': 70,
         'petz:snow_leopard': 50,
         'water_life:beaver': 48,
         'water_life:croc': 44,
         'mobs_banshee:banshee': 40,
         'water_life:whale': 40,
         'mobs_animal:sheep_brown': 36,
         'petz:polar_bear': 30,
         'flower_cow:flower_cow': 28,
         'yl_commons:biome_cow': 27,
         'mobs_animal:sheep_dark_grey': 19,
         'mobs_monster:sand_monster': 17,
         'scorpion:big': 14,
         'water_life:clownfish': 11,
         'mobs_animal:sheep_grey': 9,
         'water_life:urchin': 6,
         'petz:penguin': 5,
         'scorpion:boss': 1,
         'petz:clownfish': 1,
         'petz:tropicalfish': 1,
         'mobs_balrog:balrog': 1})
individual spawn counts of mobs in a 24 hour period, from Alias. note that some mobs, e.g. petz:wolf, spawn in clusters, so their numbers are inflated: ```python3 Counter({'yl_nether_mobs:whip': 2300, 'mobs_mime:mime': 2072, 'petz:wolf': 1554, 'nether_mobs:netherman': 1547, 'petz:tarantula': 1526, 'yl_nether_mobs:witherskeleton': 1412, 'yl_nether_mobs:rat': 1312, 'mobs_monster:oerkki': 1271, 'water_life:snake': 1237, 'mobs_monster:stone_monster': 1217, 'petz:bat': 1200, 'yl_nether_mobs:evoker': 1038, 'mobs_animal:rat': 957, 'yl_nether_mobs:ogre': 956, 'petz:bunny': 902, 'petz:piggy': 868, 'water_life:gull': 862, 'scorpion:little': 855, 'mobs_ghost_redo:ghost': 771, 'petz:squirrel': 715, 'petz:pony': 595, 'mobs_animal:bunny': 593, 'yl_nether_mobs:wither': 585, 'mobs_monster:spider': 555, 'petz:hamster': 535, 'petz:silkworm': 530, 'petz:moth': 488, 'mobs_monster:tree_monster': 471, 'petz:lamb': 470, 'petz:foxy': 465, 'petz:calf': 452, 'mobs_animal:sheep_white': 446, 'petz:goat': 436, 'mobs_animal:kitten': 430, 'water_life:gecko': 418, 'petz:grizzly': 399, 'petz:kitty': 346, 'yl_nether_mobs:blaze': 340, 'mobs_monster:dirt_monster': 333, 'mobs_animal:cow': 320, 'mobs_animal:chicken': 314, 'petz:dolphin': 290, 'petz:pigeon': 285, 'petz:rat': 270, 'mobs_animal:pumba': 253, 'mobs_others:snow_walker': 251, 'yl_nether_mobs:iron_golem': 236, 'mobs_umbra:umbra': 228, 'petz:queen_ant': 217, 'petz:turtle': 215, 'petz:elephant_female': 213, 'mobs_gazer:gazer': 201, 'mobs_animal:bee': 200, 'mobs_monster:dungeon_master': 196, 'petz:elephant': 196, 'petz:gecko': 194, 'petz:flamingo': 194, 'water_life:piranha': 193, 'petz:ducky': 192, 'petz:puppy': 187, 'petz:hen': 182, 'mobs_monster:mese_monster': 179, 'water_life:fish': 179, 'petz:frog': 178, 'petz:butterfly': 171, 'petz:lion': 167, 'mobs_monster:land_guard': 147, 'water_life:jellyfish': 143, 'petz:leopard': 136, 'petz:chimp': 127, 'petz:parrot': 126, 'petz:panda': 122, 'water_life:coralfish': 122, 'water_life:clams': 116, 'mobs_animal:panda': 114, 'water_life:shark': 112, 'petz:toucan': 103, 'petz:beaver': 85, 'mobs_monster:lava_flan': 81, 'petz:camel': 76, 'mobs_animal:sheep_black': 74, 'petz:queen_bee': 70, 'petz:snow_leopard': 50, 'water_life:beaver': 48, 'water_life:croc': 44, 'mobs_banshee:banshee': 40, 'water_life:whale': 40, 'mobs_animal:sheep_brown': 36, 'petz:polar_bear': 30, 'flower_cow:flower_cow': 28, 'yl_commons:biome_cow': 27, 'mobs_animal:sheep_dark_grey': 19, 'mobs_monster:sand_monster': 17, 'scorpion:big': 14, 'water_life:clownfish': 11, 'mobs_animal:sheep_grey': 9, 'water_life:urchin': 6, 'petz:penguin': 5, 'scorpion:boss': 1, 'petz:clownfish': 1, 'petz:tropicalfish': 1, 'mobs_balrog:balrog': 1}) ```
flux added this to the flux's TODO list project 2023-12-21 00:06:44 +00:00
flux self-assigned this 2023-12-21 00:06:47 +00:00
flux added the
4. step/at work
 label 2023-12-21 00:06:58 +00:00
AzelfYL commented 2024-01-10 08:49:49 +00:00
Copy Link

Hmm, was wondering why boss scorpions seemed to spawn far rarer than previously...

also this experiment proves dragons spawn rarer than balrogs

Hmm, was wondering why boss scorpions seemed to spawn far rarer than previously... ~~also this experiment proves dragons spawn rarer than balrogs~~
flux commented 2024-01-10 19:18:17 +00:00
Member
Copy Link

Hmm, was wondering why boss scorpions seemed to spawn far rarer than previously...

rechecking the math, they're currently 1/10th as likely as a big scorpion, whereas they used to only be 1/2 as likely. easy fix.. 0d937e8064

> Hmm, was wondering why boss scorpions seemed to spawn far rarer than previously... rechecking the math, they're currently 1/10th as likely as a big scorpion, whereas they used to only be 1/2 as likely. easy fix.. https://gitea.your-land.de/flux/yl_spawnit/commit/0d937e8064dcc6f54a38ce49fac17d9d3445ad79
flux commented 2024-01-10 19:21:09 +00:00
Member
Copy Link

also, the above table, but broken up into blocks by "type"

         'yl_nether_mobs:whip': 2300,
         'nether_mobs:netherman': 1547,
         'yl_nether_mobs:witherskeleton': 1412,
         'yl_nether_mobs:rat': 1312,
         'yl_nether_mobs:evoker': 1038,
         'yl_nether_mobs:ogre': 956,
         'yl_nether_mobs:wither': 585,
         'yl_nether_mobs:blaze': 340,
         'yl_nether_mobs:iron_golem': 236,

         'petz:wolf': 1554,  # 4
         'petz:tarantula': 1526,
         'petz:bat': 1200,
         'petz:bunny': 902,  # 3
         'petz:piggy': 868,  # 3
         'petz:squirrel': 715,  # 3
         'petz:pony': 595,  # 5
         'petz:hamster': 535,
         'petz:silkworm': 530,
         'petz:moth': 488,
         'petz:lamb': 470,  # 3
         'petz:foxy': 465,
         'petz:calf': 452,  # 3
         'petz:goat': 436,  # 3
         'petz:grizzly': 399,
         'petz:kitty': 346,
         'petz:dolphin': 290,
         'petz:pigeon': 285,
         'petz:rat': 270,
         'petz:queen_ant': 217,
         'petz:turtle': 215,
         'petz:elephant_female': 213,
         'petz:elephant': 196,
         'petz:gecko': 194,
         'petz:flamingo': 194,
         'petz:ducky': 192,
         'petz:puppy': 187,
         'petz:hen': 182,
         'petz:frog': 178,
         'petz:butterfly': 171,
         'petz:lion': 167,
         'petz:leopard': 136,
         'petz:chimp': 127,
         'petz:parrot': 126,
         'petz:panda': 122,
         'petz:toucan': 103,
         'petz:beaver': 85,
         'petz:camel': 76,
         'petz:queen_bee': 70,
         'petz:snow_leopard': 50,
         'petz:polar_bear': 30,
         'petz:penguin': 5,
         'petz:clownfish': 1,
         'petz:tropicalfish': 1,

         'mobs_mime:mime': 2072,
         'mobs_ghost_redo:ghost': 771,
         'mobs_others:snow_walker': 251,
         'mobs_umbra:umbra': 228,
         'mobs_gazer:gazer': 201,
         'mobs_banshee:banshee': 40,
         'flower_cow:flower_cow': 28,
         'yl_commons:biome_cow': 27,
         'mobs_balrog:balrog': 1,

         'mobs_animal:rat': 957,
         'mobs_animal:bunny': 593,
         'mobs_animal:sheep_white': 446,
         'mobs_animal:kitten': 430,
         'mobs_animal:cow': 320,
         'mobs_animal:chicken': 314,
         'mobs_animal:pumba': 253,
         'mobs_animal:bee': 200,
         'mobs_animal:panda': 114,
         'mobs_animal:sheep_black': 74,
         'mobs_animal:sheep_brown': 36,
         'mobs_animal:sheep_dark_grey': 19,
         'mobs_animal:sheep_grey': 9,

         'mobs_monster:oerkki': 1271,
         'mobs_monster:stone_monster': 1217,
         'mobs_monster:spider': 555,
         'mobs_monster:tree_monster': 471,
         'mobs_monster:dirt_monster': 333,
         'mobs_monster:dungeon_master': 196,
         'mobs_monster:mese_monster': 179,
         'mobs_monster:land_guard': 147,
         'mobs_monster:lava_flan': 81,
         'mobs_monster:sand_monster': 17,

         'scorpion:little': 855,
         'scorpion:big': 14,
         'scorpion:boss': 1,

         'water_life:snake': 1237,
         'water_life:gull': 862,
         'water_life:gecko': 418,
         'water_life:piranha': 193,
         'water_life:fish': 179,
         'water_life:jellyfish': 143,
         'water_life:coralfish': 122,
         'water_life:clams': 116,
         'water_life:shark': 112,
         'water_life:beaver': 48,
         'water_life:croc': 44,
         'water_life:whale': 40,
         'water_life:clownfish': 11,
         'water_life:urchin': 6,
also, the above table, but broken up into blocks by "type" ```python 'yl_nether_mobs:whip': 2300, 'nether_mobs:netherman': 1547, 'yl_nether_mobs:witherskeleton': 1412, 'yl_nether_mobs:rat': 1312, 'yl_nether_mobs:evoker': 1038, 'yl_nether_mobs:ogre': 956, 'yl_nether_mobs:wither': 585, 'yl_nether_mobs:blaze': 340, 'yl_nether_mobs:iron_golem': 236, 'petz:wolf': 1554, # 4 'petz:tarantula': 1526, 'petz:bat': 1200, 'petz:bunny': 902, # 3 'petz:piggy': 868, # 3 'petz:squirrel': 715, # 3 'petz:pony': 595, # 5 'petz:hamster': 535, 'petz:silkworm': 530, 'petz:moth': 488, 'petz:lamb': 470, # 3 'petz:foxy': 465, 'petz:calf': 452, # 3 'petz:goat': 436, # 3 'petz:grizzly': 399, 'petz:kitty': 346, 'petz:dolphin': 290, 'petz:pigeon': 285, 'petz:rat': 270, 'petz:queen_ant': 217, 'petz:turtle': 215, 'petz:elephant_female': 213, 'petz:elephant': 196, 'petz:gecko': 194, 'petz:flamingo': 194, 'petz:ducky': 192, 'petz:puppy': 187, 'petz:hen': 182, 'petz:frog': 178, 'petz:butterfly': 171, 'petz:lion': 167, 'petz:leopard': 136, 'petz:chimp': 127, 'petz:parrot': 126, 'petz:panda': 122, 'petz:toucan': 103, 'petz:beaver': 85, 'petz:camel': 76, 'petz:queen_bee': 70, 'petz:snow_leopard': 50, 'petz:polar_bear': 30, 'petz:penguin': 5, 'petz:clownfish': 1, 'petz:tropicalfish': 1, 'mobs_mime:mime': 2072, 'mobs_ghost_redo:ghost': 771, 'mobs_others:snow_walker': 251, 'mobs_umbra:umbra': 228, 'mobs_gazer:gazer': 201, 'mobs_banshee:banshee': 40, 'flower_cow:flower_cow': 28, 'yl_commons:biome_cow': 27, 'mobs_balrog:balrog': 1, 'mobs_animal:rat': 957, 'mobs_animal:bunny': 593, 'mobs_animal:sheep_white': 446, 'mobs_animal:kitten': 430, 'mobs_animal:cow': 320, 'mobs_animal:chicken': 314, 'mobs_animal:pumba': 253, 'mobs_animal:bee': 200, 'mobs_animal:panda': 114, 'mobs_animal:sheep_black': 74, 'mobs_animal:sheep_brown': 36, 'mobs_animal:sheep_dark_grey': 19, 'mobs_animal:sheep_grey': 9, 'mobs_monster:oerkki': 1271, 'mobs_monster:stone_monster': 1217, 'mobs_monster:spider': 555, 'mobs_monster:tree_monster': 471, 'mobs_monster:dirt_monster': 333, 'mobs_monster:dungeon_master': 196, 'mobs_monster:mese_monster': 179, 'mobs_monster:land_guard': 147, 'mobs_monster:lava_flan': 81, 'mobs_monster:sand_monster': 17, 'scorpion:little': 855, 'scorpion:big': 14, 'scorpion:boss': 1, 'water_life:snake': 1237, 'water_life:gull': 862, 'water_life:gecko': 418, 'water_life:piranha': 193, 'water_life:fish': 179, 'water_life:jellyfish': 143, 'water_life:coralfish': 122, 'water_life:clams': 116, 'water_life:shark': 112, 'water_life:beaver': 48, 'water_life:croc': 44, 'water_life:whale': 40, 'water_life:clownfish': 11, 'water_life:urchin': 6, ```
flux commented 2024-01-13 17:51:26 +00:00
Member
Copy Link

clams seem to be totally ignoring the density rules (near 6100, 0, 2100). there should only be at most 6 in a sphere of radius 24.

image

clams seem to be totally ignoring the density rules (near 6100, 0, 2100). there should only be at most 6 in a sphere of radius 24. ![image](/attachments/a56ccb5f-97fc-4af6-b811-7250c3566d09)
flux commented 2024-01-13 19:24:34 +00:00
Member
Copy Link

clams are properly limited in other parts of the server. hm.

clams are properly limited in other parts of the server. hm.
AliasAlreadyTaken commented 2024-01-13 19:31:51 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link

This isn't some testing ground by any chance? Where we for some forgotten reason manually spawned in clams? Maybe to test their longevity in bad temperatures?

This isn't some testing ground by any chance? Where we for some forgotten reason manually spawned in clams? Maybe to test their longevity in bad temperatures?
flux commented 2024-01-13 19:40:44 +00:00
Member
Copy Link

alias gave me 27.5 days worth of spawnit logs. here's the breakdown:

  43877 mobs_mime:mime
  16371 mobs_ghost_redo:ghost
   7143 mobs_others:snow_walker
   4368 mobs_umbra:umbra
   4234 mobs_gazer:gazer
    712 mobs_banshee:banshee
     26 mobs_balrog:balrog
--------------------------
  76731 total

  29671 water_life:snake
  22492 water_life:gull
   6700 water_life:gecko
   5653 water_life:coralfish
   2958 water_life:clams
   2607 water_life:jellyfish
   2142 water_life:piranha
   2010 water_life:fish
   1450 water_life:shark
    826 water_life:urchin
    782 water_life:whale
    696 water_life:beaver
    452 water_life:croc
    263 water_life:clownfish
--------------------------
  78702 total

  29402 yl_nether_mobs:whip
  22826 nether_mobs:netherman
  22038 yl_nether_mobs:witherskeleton
  18013 yl_nether_mobs:rat
  16996 yl_nether_mobs:ogre
  15378 yl_nether_mobs:evoker
  11817 yl_nether_mobs:blaze
   9249 yl_nether_mobs:wither
   3758 yl_nether_mobs:iron_golem
      1 nether_mobs:dragon
--------------------------
 149478 total

  27459 mobs_monster:oerkki
  26297 mobs_monster:stone_monster
  15177 mobs_monster:spider
   7789 mobs_monster:tree_monster
   5436 mobs_monster:dirt_monster
   4208 mobs_monster:dungeon_master
   3929 mobs_monster:mese_monster
   3203 mobs_monster:land_guard
   2828 mobs_monster:lava_flan
    253 mobs_monster:sand_monster
    175 mobs_monster:fire_spirit
--------------------------
  96754 total

  31853 petz:tarantula
  26263 petz:bat
  26224 petz:wolf
  15027 petz:bunny
  14155 petz:piggy
  12709 petz:squirrel
  12175 petz:moth
  10193 petz:pony
   9585 petz:hamster
   9269 petz:silkworm
   7914 petz:lamb
   7335 petz:pigeon
   7247 petz:foxy
   7152 petz:goat
   6762 petz:calf
   6229 petz:dolphin
   5673 petz:rat
   5346 petz:kitty
   5228 petz:grizzly
   4125 petz:turtle
   3961 petz:ducky
   3893 petz:elephant_female
   3865 petz:queen_ant
   3550 petz:lion
   3453 petz:elephant
   3367 petz:flamingo
   3266 petz:leopard
   3251 petz:hen
   3092 petz:gecko
   2995 petz:puppy
   2814 petz:butterfly
   2803 petz:frog
   2202 petz:snow_leopard
   2182 petz:chimp
   1927 petz:parrot
   1808 petz:toucan
   1549 petz:polar_bear
   1449 petz:camel
   1314 petz:beaver
   1268 petz:panda
   1125 petz:queen_bee
    146 petz:penguin
     73 petz:clownfish
     20 petz:tropicalfish
--------------------------
 285837 total

  20729 mobs_animal:rat
   9843 mobs_animal:bunny
   7659 mobs_animal:sheep_white
   6791 mobs_animal:kitten
   5354 mobs_animal:chicken
   5286 mobs_animal:pumba
   5243 mobs_animal:cow
   3074 mobs_animal:bee
   1598 mobs_animal:panda
   1273 mobs_animal:sheep_black
    629 mobs_animal:sheep_brown
    333 mobs_animal:sheep_grey
    308 mobs_animal:sheep_dark_grey
     71 mobs_animal:penguin
--------------------------
  68191 total

  15098 scorpion:little
    150 scorpion:big
     27 scorpion:boss
--------------------------
  15275 total

    546 yl_commons:biome_cow
    456 flower_cow:flower_cow
--------------------------
   1002 total
alias gave me 27.5 days worth of spawnit logs. here's the breakdown: ``` 43877 mobs_mime:mime 16371 mobs_ghost_redo:ghost 7143 mobs_others:snow_walker 4368 mobs_umbra:umbra 4234 mobs_gazer:gazer 712 mobs_banshee:banshee 26 mobs_balrog:balrog -------------------------- 76731 total 29671 water_life:snake 22492 water_life:gull 6700 water_life:gecko 5653 water_life:coralfish 2958 water_life:clams 2607 water_life:jellyfish 2142 water_life:piranha 2010 water_life:fish 1450 water_life:shark 826 water_life:urchin 782 water_life:whale 696 water_life:beaver 452 water_life:croc 263 water_life:clownfish -------------------------- 78702 total 29402 yl_nether_mobs:whip 22826 nether_mobs:netherman 22038 yl_nether_mobs:witherskeleton 18013 yl_nether_mobs:rat 16996 yl_nether_mobs:ogre 15378 yl_nether_mobs:evoker 11817 yl_nether_mobs:blaze 9249 yl_nether_mobs:wither 3758 yl_nether_mobs:iron_golem 1 nether_mobs:dragon -------------------------- 149478 total 27459 mobs_monster:oerkki 26297 mobs_monster:stone_monster 15177 mobs_monster:spider 7789 mobs_monster:tree_monster 5436 mobs_monster:dirt_monster 4208 mobs_monster:dungeon_master 3929 mobs_monster:mese_monster 3203 mobs_monster:land_guard 2828 mobs_monster:lava_flan 253 mobs_monster:sand_monster 175 mobs_monster:fire_spirit -------------------------- 96754 total 31853 petz:tarantula 26263 petz:bat 26224 petz:wolf 15027 petz:bunny 14155 petz:piggy 12709 petz:squirrel 12175 petz:moth 10193 petz:pony 9585 petz:hamster 9269 petz:silkworm 7914 petz:lamb 7335 petz:pigeon 7247 petz:foxy 7152 petz:goat 6762 petz:calf 6229 petz:dolphin 5673 petz:rat 5346 petz:kitty 5228 petz:grizzly 4125 petz:turtle 3961 petz:ducky 3893 petz:elephant_female 3865 petz:queen_ant 3550 petz:lion 3453 petz:elephant 3367 petz:flamingo 3266 petz:leopard 3251 petz:hen 3092 petz:gecko 2995 petz:puppy 2814 petz:butterfly 2803 petz:frog 2202 petz:snow_leopard 2182 petz:chimp 1927 petz:parrot 1808 petz:toucan 1549 petz:polar_bear 1449 petz:camel 1314 petz:beaver 1268 petz:panda 1125 petz:queen_bee 146 petz:penguin 73 petz:clownfish 20 petz:tropicalfish -------------------------- 285837 total 20729 mobs_animal:rat 9843 mobs_animal:bunny 7659 mobs_animal:sheep_white 6791 mobs_animal:kitten 5354 mobs_animal:chicken 5286 mobs_animal:pumba 5243 mobs_animal:cow 3074 mobs_animal:bee 1598 mobs_animal:panda 1273 mobs_animal:sheep_black 629 mobs_animal:sheep_brown 333 mobs_animal:sheep_grey 308 mobs_animal:sheep_dark_grey 71 mobs_animal:penguin -------------------------- 68191 total 15098 scorpion:little 150 scorpion:big 27 scorpion:boss -------------------------- 15275 total 546 yl_commons:biome_cow 456 flower_cow:flower_cow -------------------------- 1002 total ```
flux commented 2024-01-13 20:08:41 +00:00
Member
Copy Link

tweaked the spawn rates according to those numbers 2ec89da73f

tweaked the spawn rates according to those numbers https://gitea.your-land.de/flux/yl_spawnit/commit/2ec89da73fcdeaedf44cd922c7654ad2e4793b41
flux commented 2024-01-13 20:19:35 +00:00
Member
Copy Link
2023-12-30 16:46:20: ACTION[Server]: [spawnit] water_life:clams @ (6096,-4,2119) activates in INACTIVE mapblock
2023-12-30 16:46:20: ACTION[Server]: [spawnit] spawned water_life:clams @ (6096,-4,2119)
2023-12-30 16:46:21: ACTION[Server]: [spawnit] water_life:clams @ (6096,-4,2119) was deactivated after 0.841s (true)

hmm.

``` 2023-12-30 16:46:20: ACTION[Server]: [spawnit] water_life:clams @ (6096,-4,2119) activates in INACTIVE mapblock 2023-12-30 16:46:20: ACTION[Server]: [spawnit] spawned water_life:clams @ (6096,-4,2119) 2023-12-30 16:46:21: ACTION[Server]: [spawnit] water_life:clams @ (6096,-4,2119) was deactivated after 0.841s (true) ``` hmm.
flux commented 2024-01-13 20:32:44 +00:00
Member
Copy Link

it seems that spawnit is creating clams in a place that the server things is inactive for objects but which spawnit thinks is active? so they end up piling up, because they unload immediately. it seems this area is frequently activated and then deactivated quickly thereafter, which might be why it's so bad in this one place. probably the best solution here is to add the clams to the culler.

it seems that spawnit is creating clams in a place that the server things is inactive for objects but which spawnit thinks is active? so they end up piling up, because they unload immediately. it seems this area is frequently activated and then deactivated quickly thereafter, which might be why it's so bad in this one place. probably the best solution here is to add the clams to the culler.
AzelfYL commented 2024-01-15 14:19:06 +00:00
Copy Link

am i the only one who thinks that the number of whips spawning in the nether should be cut down a bit?

am i the only one who thinks that the number of whips spawning in the nether should be cut down a bit?
flux commented 2024-01-15 17:16:43 +00:00
Member
Copy Link

am i the only one who thinks that the number of whips spawning in the nether should be cut down a bit?

sure, that seems reasonable. halved it 04c4aebf26

> am i the only one who thinks that the number of whips spawning in the nether should be cut down a bit? sure, that seems reasonable. halved it https://gitea.your-land.de/flux/yl_spawnit/commit/04c4aebf26b26cb96ca263595bbfb08a44d79f57
daydream commented 2024-01-30 06:27:07 +00:00
Member
Copy Link

any way to remove the thousands of wild area animal spawns that are just everywhere near where anybody was doing anything the last few weeks?

any way to remove the thousands of wild area animal spawns that are just everywhere near where anybody was doing anything the last few weeks?
flux commented 2024-01-30 21:17:39 +00:00
Member
Copy Link

any way to remove the thousands of wild area animal spawns that are just everywhere near where anybody was doing anything the last few weeks?

we can tweak the culling rules, though i wonder what would be appropriate.

> any way to remove the thousands of wild area animal spawns that are just everywhere near where anybody was doing anything the last few weeks? we can tweak the culling rules, though i wonder what would be appropriate.
AliasAlreadyTaken commented 2024-01-31 04:11:44 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link

Will that problem not solve itself, by spawning less and lifetimer still in place?

Will that problem not solve itself, by spawning less and lifetimer still in place?
flux commented 2024-02-01 00:02:45 +00:00
Member
Copy Link

lifetimer still in place

petz don't have a lifetimer unless tamagochi mode is enabled, which is part of the petz problem.

> lifetimer still in place petz don't have a lifetimer unless tamagochi mode is enabled, which is part of the petz problem.
flux commented 2024-02-01 00:05:12 +00:00
Member
Copy Link

thousands of wild area animal spawns

image

the number of active entities is pretty much your-land normal (it ranges between around 2000 and 8000 depending on how many players are active and where they are), but the # spawned since server start is ... concerning, i suppose.

> thousands of wild area animal spawns ![image](/attachments/8ca67d65-c11f-488e-98a8-61f7ba5d5f1c) the number of active entities is pretty much your-land normal (it ranges between around 2000 and 8000 depending on how many players are active and where they are), but the # spawned since server start is ... concerning, i suppose.
image.png
12 KiB
flux commented 2024-02-01 00:14:03 +00:00
Member
Copy Link

i added limits for all petz and increased the effective radius: c37fee4d81

i added limits for all petz and increased the effective radius: https://gitea.your-land.de/your-land/yl_commons/commit/c37fee4d81b7bdeca080669131aa52adc52ca3d0
flux commented 2024-02-08 20:59:21 +00:00
Member
Copy Link

Increase the rate of boss scorpions spawning by a bit? It seems like their spawn rate got nuked after the update

#5691 (comment)

> Increase the rate of boss scorpions spawning by a bit? It seems like their spawn rate got nuked after the update https://gitea.your-land.de/your-land/bugtracker/issues/5691#issuecomment-70738
flux commented 2024-03-30 19:15:52 +00:00
Member
Copy Link

i think we should close this, but still field requests for further balancing. thoughts?

i think we should close this, but still field requests for further balancing. thoughts?
AzelfYL commented 2024-03-31 04:35:12 +00:00
Copy Link

I think we should just keep this issue open unless absolutely no mob spawning issues occur within the next few months.

I think we should just keep this issue open unless absolutely no mob spawning issues occur within the next few months.
👍 1
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Branch/Tag Specified
Branches Tags
Labels
Clear labels   
1. kind/balancing

Depends on balancing

  
1. kind/breaking

something that alters or disables an existing game mechanic

  
1. kind/bug

Something is not working

  
1. kind/construction

A build needs fixing

  
1. kind/documentation

Needs proper documentation

  
1. kind/enhancement

New feature

  
1. kind/griefing

players despoiling builds or nature

  
1. kind/invalid

Not a valid report, e.g. created by mistake with no content.

  
1. kind/meme

issue is mostly a joke

  
1. kind/node limit

something which works for or against the node limit

  
1. kind/other

Something not within the other kinds

  
1. kind/protocol

something concerning how staff should react to player requests, or how players should treat each other

  
2. prio/controversial

not likely to happen w/out a lot of discussion

  
2. prio/critical

Very important

  
2. prio/elevated

something players are eager to have fixed

  
2. prio/good first issue

the resolution to this is could be done by a new minetest contributor, who doesn't yet understand the mod ecosystem

  
2. prio/interesting

one of us has real interest in getting this implemented or fixed. however, more research might be needed.

  
2. prio/low

Not so important

  
3. source/art

art needs to be created or found for this to exist. includes sound, 3d modelling, and in-game building.

  
3. source/client

Issue is with the minetest client, or with player client configuration or the technical details of their setup

  
3. source/engine

Issue is due to a bug or feature of the minetest engine

  
3. source/ingame

Problem and solution exist in-game, e.g. builds or player moderation

  
3. source/integration

Two or more nonbuggy mechanics conflict, or our attempts to rectify conflicting mechanics have created a new bug

  
3. source/lag

A problem which is caused or made worse by lag, due to server processing issues, client processing issues, or network issues

  
3. source/license

A licensing problem is involved

  
3. source/mod upstream

Problem is upstream (not engine/client)

  
3. source/unknown

   
3. source/website

Affects the website

  
4. step/approved

Alias has approved this feature, someone should implement it

  
4. step/at work

Being worked on

  
4. step/blocked

we plan to do this, but other work has to be finished first

  
4. step/discussion

issue is under discussion, a solution has not been dictated or agreed upon

  
4. step/help wanted

Need some help

  
4. step/needs confirmation

   
4. step/partially fixed

this is mitigated or partially solved, but more work needs to be done

  
4. step/question

More information is needed

  
4. step/ready to deploy

has been QA tested by another person. has no outstanding issues. might be installed on prod, but needs final testing

  
4. step/ready to QA test

the code is supposedly fixed, but needs to be tested.

  
4. step/want approval

Someone can quickly implement this if Alias approves the change/feature

  
5. result/cannot reproduce

   
5. result/duplicate

This issue or pull request already exists

  
5. result/fixed

problem is fixed

  
5. result/maybe

not planned currently, but maybe some day

  
5. result/wontfix

the reported issue won't be changed, whether it's intentional or not.

  
ugh/petz

yet another petz bugz.

  
ugh/QA main

That's something we can only wait and see whether it hapens again: On the main server

  
ugh/QA NOK

Fix didn't yield the expected results

  
ugh/QA OK

tested

No Label
1. kind/balancing
1. kind/breaking
1. kind/bug
1. kind/construction
1. kind/documentation
1. kind/enhancement
1. kind/griefing
1. kind/invalid
1. kind/meme
1. kind/node limit
1. kind/other
1. kind/protocol
2. prio/controversial
2. prio/critical
2. prio/elevated
2. prio/good first issue
2. prio/interesting
2. prio/low
3. source/art
3. source/client
3. source/engine
3. source/ingame
3. source/integration
3. source/lag
3. source/license
3. source/mod upstream
3. source/unknown
3. source/website
4. step/approved
4. step/at work
4. step/blocked
4. step/discussion
4. step/help wanted
4. step/needs confirmation
4. step/partially fixed
4. step/question
4. step/ready to deploy
4. step/ready to QA test
4. step/want approval
5. result/cannot reproduce
5. result/duplicate
5. result/fixed
5. result/maybe
5. result/wontfix
ugh/petz
ugh/QA main
ugh/QA NOK
ugh/QA OK
Milestone
Clear milestone
No items
No Milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No project
flux's TODO list
Assignees
Clear assignees
No Assignees
flux
4 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format 'yyyy-mm-dd'.

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: your-land/bugtracker#5691
No description provided.
Delete Branch "%!s(<nil>)"

Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?